Eventful life stories

Erich Arak’s manuscript

Keywords: life stories, memory, autobiography, narrativity, World War II in ­Estonia


This paper focuses on a contextual analysis of a 250-page manuscript life story written by an Estonian man born in 1921, who survived mobilization into both World War II occupation armies, subsequent imprisonment in the Siberian Gulag, and later, after a failed escape attempt, several years of imprisonment and re­settlement in the Kolyma mining district in the Far East. The text was submitted posthumously to an Estonian life story collection competition in 2004. In this paper, Erich Arak’s manuscript is used as an example to develop the concept of an “eventful” life narrative, both as the kaleidoscopic cumulation of narrated experiences and the resultant epic dimension of the story’s poetics. Vieda Skultans and James Wertsch’s terms “cultural” and “textual resources,” and Leona Toker’s concepts of “mixed metaphors” and “co-lamination” (as seen in Gulag literature) enable the discussion of the paradoxical relationship of Arak’s life story’s ethical substrate and aesthetic effects. The proposed analysis is complementary  – perhaps even cautionary – with regard to methodological approaches that (skeptically, even suspiciously) diagnose and classify life stories according to discourses of nationalism, resistance, rupture, and nostalgia.


Tiina Kirss (b. 1957), PhD, Estonian Literary Museum, University of Tartu, Senior Researcher,



EKM EKLA – Eesti Kirjandusmuuseumi Eesti Kultuurilooline Arhiiv

F 350, nr 1787. Arak, Erich

F 350, nr 1741. Raag, Boris



A a r e l a i d, Aili 2006. Cultural Trauma and Life Stories. Helsinki: University of Helsinki Press.

A s s m a n n, Aleida 2006. Der lange Schatten der Vergangenheit: Erinnerungs­kultur und Geschichtspolitik. München: Beck.

B o y m, Svetlana 2008. Banality of Evil, Mimicry, and the Soviet Subject: Varlam Shalamov and Hannah Arendt. – Slavic Review, kd 67, nr 2, lk 342–363.

C a v a r e r o, Adriana 2000. Relating Narratives: Storytelling and Selfhood. London: Routledge.

C o n q u e s t, Robert 1978. Kolyma: The Arctic Death Camps. New York: Viking.

E a k i n, John Paul 1999. How our Lives Become Stories: Making Selves. Ithaca: Cornell UP.

G i l m o r e, Leigh 2001. The Limits of Autobiography: Trauma and Testimony. Ithaca: Cornell UP.

G u l l e s t a d, Marianne 1996. Everyday Life Philosophers: Modernity, Morality, and Autobiography in Norway. Oslo: Scandinavian University Press.

H i n r i k u s, Rutt (koost) 1999. Me tulime tagasi. Tartu: Eesti Kirjandusmuuseum.

J a a g o, Tiiu 2011. The Lucky Star and discernment: the positioning of the self and war in the life story of Lembitu Varblane. – Soldiers of Memory: World War II and its Aftermath in Estonian Post-Soviet Life Stories. Toim Ene Kõresaar. Amsterdam: Rodopi, lk 317–342.

K i r s s, Tiina 2006. Mäletamine ja veendumus. Ühe eesti mehe elu lood. – Ruti raamat. Artikleid, lugusid ja mälestusi. Pühendusteos Rutt Hinrikusele 7. 05. 2006. (EKLA töid kirjandusest ja kultuuriloost 4.) Tartu: Eesti Kirjandusmuuseum, lk 109–128.

K i r s s, Tiina Ann 2011. When is the war over? Ylo-Vesse Velvelt’s life story and surviving the ’Czech Hell’. – Soldiers of Memory: World War II and its Aftermath in Estonian Post-Soviet Life Stories. Toim Ene Kõresaar. Amsterdam: Rodopi, lk 365–385.

K i r s s, Tiina, K i v i m ä e, Jüri 2009. Estonian life stories and histories. – Estonian Life Stories. Toim T. Kirss. Budapest: Central European University Press, lk 1−33.

K i r s s, Tiina, K õ r e s a a r, Ene, L a u r i s t i n, Marju (toim) 2005. She Who Remembers Survives. Interpreting Estonian Women’s Post-Soviet Life Stories. Tartu: Tartu Ülikooli Kirjastus.

K r o s s, Jaan 2003. Kallid kaasteelised. Tallinn: Eesti Keele Sihtasutus.

K õ r e s a a r, Ene 2008. Nostalgia ja selle puudumine eestlaste mälukultuuris. ­Eluloouurija vaatepunkt. – Keel ja Kirjandus, nr 10, lk 760–773.

L a a n e s, Eneken 2017. Trauma keelde tõlgitud: kultuurideülesed mäluvormid eesti laagri- ja küüditamismälestustes. – Keel ja Kirjandus, nr 4, lk 241–257.

L e j e u n e, Philippe 1975. Le pacte autobiographique. Paris: Seuil.

L o t m a n, Juri M. 1990 [1984]. Õigus biograafiale. Teksti ja autori isiksuse tüpoloogilisest suhestatusest. – J. Lotman, Kultuurisemiootika. Tallinn: Olion, lk 365–385.

M a r t s o n, Ilona 2007. Üksi rändan… – Sirp 28. IX.

M e r t e l s m a n n, Olaf 2011. Boris Raag – „Hope of Staying Alive”: Survival strategies of a Soviet soldier. – Soldiers of Memory: World War II and its Aftermath in Estonian Post-Soviet Life Stories. Toim Ene Kõresaar. Amsterdam: Rodopi, lk 263–279.

N õ l v a k, Valentine 2007. Ellujääja. Mälestused. Tallinn: Varrak.

P a l m e n f e l t, Ulf  2006. The dark shadow of the un-mentioned event: Collapsing taleworlds and narrative reparation. – Narrating, Doing, Experiencing: Nordic Folkloristic Perspectives. (Studia Fennica Folkloristica 16.) Toim Annikki ­Kaivola-Bregenhøj, Barbro Klein, U. Palmenfelt. Helsinki: Suomalaisen Kirjallisuuden Seura, lk 101–116.

P o r t e l l i, Alessandro 1991. The Death of Luigi Trastulli and other Stories: Form and Meaning in Oral History. Albany: State University of New York Press.

R a h i - T a m m, Aigi 2011. „Alexander Loog – Searching for one’s way”. – Soldiers of Memory: World War II and its Aftermath in Estonian Post-Soviet Life Stories. Toim Ene Kõresaar. Amsterdam: Rodopi, lk 235–262.

R ü ü t e l, Ronald 2002. Atarma: minu elu Siberis. Tallinn: Faatum.

S h a l a m o v, Varlam 1980. Kolyma Tales. Tlk inglise keelde John Glad. London: Norton.

S k u l t a n s, Vieda 1998. The Testimony of Lives. London: Routledge.

S o m m e r, Doris 1988. Not just a personal story: Women’s testimonios and the plural self. –  Life/Lines: Theorizing Women’s Autobiography. Toim Bella Brodzki, Celeste Schenk. Ithaka: Cornell University Press, lk 107–131.

S u b b i, Ülo 2008. Lõpp hea – kõik hea! Mälestusi pikalt elurajalt. Tartu: Kuldsulg.

S w e e t W o n g, Herta D. 1998. First-person plural: Subjectivity and community in native American women’s autobiography. – Women, Autobiography, and Theory: A Reader. Toim Sidonie Smith, Julia Watson. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, lk 168–182.

T o k e r, Leona 2000. Return from the Archipelago: Narratives of Gulag Survivors. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.

T u l v i n g, Endel 2007. Mälu. Tlk Jüri Allik. Tartu: Tartu Ülikooli Kirjastus.

U s a i, Urmas (koost) 1993. Eestlased tööpataljonides 1941–1942. I kd. Tallinn: Olion.

W e r t s c h, James V. 2002. Voices of Collective Remembering. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

W h i t e, Hayden 1980. The value of narrativity in the representation of reality. – Critical Inquiry, kd 7, nr 1, lk 5–27.

Õ u n, Mati 2015. Laevahukud Läänemerel 20. sajandi sõdades. Tallinn: Grenader.

Y o u n g, Sarah J. 2011. Recalling the dead: Representing identity and witness in Varlam Shalamov’s Kolyma tales. – Slavic Review, kd 70, nr 2, lk 353–372.